Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Google's Knol experiment to rival Wikipedia?
Vault9 Forums > Tech Den > Teh Interwebs

Custom Search
RenegadeNukes
QUOTE
Last night on the official Google blog, Udi Manber, vice president of engineering, announced that Google is testing a publishing platform called Knol.

It\'s being compared to Wikipedia and Mahalo. While it\'s a somewhat different take on knowledge collection, these comparisons are apt.

From what we know so far, Knol is a wiki-like platform. Authors can create topics, and there are tools to interlink articles and content, but as Manber says, an article, or \"knol,\" is \"just a Web page.\" Where it differs from a wiki is its focus on the author. All knols will highlight who wrote them.



Knol should make it easy to create nicely formatted reference pages.

(Credit: Google) That small difference becomes dramatic when you put Knol alongside Wikipedia. Wikipedia is a collaborative system. There is no author listed on a wiki page because a page may have many authors (if you want to, you can divine who said what on the history pages).

Since Knol pages will be authored, users won\'t, presumably, be able to dive in and edit another page. They\'ll be able to submit edits to the author for approval, though. So much for open collaboration. But as a platform for authors who might want to make some money from their work, it\'s a better bet (Knol will allow authors to monetize their pages as they see fit).

Purists may think that since Google is in the business of monetizing content via advertising, it should not compete with other publishing platforms. However, this is not the first time that Google has gotten into this business.

Blogger, of course, is Google\'s biggest success in text-publishing platforms. But Google also experimented with its own database, Google Base, in which it not only indexes the information but also stores it. And then there\'s YouTube.


Read the rest here

Wow, google is taking over the internet, one step at a time. This is a good idea and from the looks of it is is pretty damn good. Don\'t know how its going to stand against the mighty open-edited Wikipedia though. Personally i like the whole author moderation thing as more often than not i have entered stuff onmto wiki[pedia and its been edited to hell and back - more than a bit annoying. Thew wiki code is also a bit 2 time consuming for me and i don\\t borther writing up complicated formatinng into it as a result.

This looks good and i\'m eagerly waiting to check this out tongue.gif

Some Links If You Are Interested

Google Blog

NEWS.COM

Search Engine Land


Reason For Edit: Added additional links to post smile.gif

BTW; Sorry for the spelling mistakes, this keyboard is very stiff and needs to be replaced tongue.gif
Surge
Hmm... This leaves the author of the article in more control. Sounds good, but what happens if you get like a thousand requests for an edit on a day?

Only time will tell how this will go up against Wiki.
RenegadeNukes
QUOTE
Hmm... This leaves the author of the article in more control. Sounds good, but what happens if you get like a thousand requests for an edit on a day?


I'm thinking about the opposite item, that an author writes something and then never bothers to come back to Knol. That article will be locked and no-one can update it, because the author has to be around the accept the edits
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Custom Search
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.