If you are into Rock / Speed Metal etc. one the biggest names in that genre is Metallica - aswell as being the highest selling Rock Artist in History they have been many peoples intro into heavier stuff

Well after 8 albums in a career spanning 20 odd years - which one do you reckon was their best?

Get the Votes In

BTW: 3 votes only

I can't vote for 1, or even 3. They are 1 super band, and I generally love all their albums.

Metallica was the best album IMO, but ride the lightning and master of puppets are also both awesome

Whoa hunter took the words right from my mouth:

Black > Ride the Lightning > Puppets

Not looking forward to their next album though, I suspect it'll be even worse than St Anger.


I believe you are mistaken sir: that honour goes to the almighty AC/DC.

Black > *

Is there any competition

ST. ANGER FOR THE WIN!!!!!!!!!!

Just joking

Well my vote will go for Master Of Puppets and RTL

Hmm... Now this is a tough one too choose.

Well my choice will have to go to Ride The Lightning > Master Of Puppets > Black

I just thought that for whom the bell tolls, fade to black and RTL itlseft were just amazing songs and out of all the albums i loved this one the most. Black and Puppets were also excellent!

Master... Master... Master of Puppets are pulling your strings, twisting your mind and smashing your dreams.



Well i have St. Anger as well and i think of it as a different departure to experimenyt with a more raw and and angry feel to the music, well it wasn't as good as some of there older stuff - but it aint bad in my opinion. I still listen to it quite a bit

Dirty Window is probably my favouriyte St. Anger track

BTW: I see someone here voted for it