Okay, I am not sure if Amy Winehouse has made it to South Africa yet, she is pretty much an amazing singer, songwriter, smoky voice full of raw emotion, etc... just listen to her latest Album BACK TO BLACK.

Now, I have a question for the guys, which Amy do you prefer, the one where she is of normal weight, pretty, gorgeous hair, everything, or the latest Amy, who is very skinny, still sexy, fierce looking?

It would be nice to hear the male opinion, since the girls I've spoken to feel pretty much as I do, that she looked better before than now.

the one on the right

and her one song is big here in SA, rehab

Sorry Hanna, but you still think the picture on the left is sexy? Wow, that freaks me out. I find the picture on the left almost repulsive......
The one on the right is definitely the best, she is/was beautiful!

she looks horrible in BOTH pictures! ew, gross.

No, I don't actually think she is sexy in the pic on the left, rather sick looking, actually, she is a major coke-head, according to friends of mine in London, which accounts for the scary weightloss.

I was just wondering, since, you know, since us women get bombarded by mixed messages all the time from the media and, though I realize that she looks scary thin in that pic, there is a big part of me who would love to look like that.

The one on the right looks way better (left is sick).

A woman needs to have some curves in order to accentuate natural beauty. Kinda like the old school models like Cindy Crawford, Claudia Schiffer, etc.

She looks dirty and annarexic in the left picture

Her shape suits a larger figure. In the left pic she just looks out of proportion.

The rehab chick is WHITE!!!

OMG... I don't get to see enough music videos I thought that chick was black LOL

---

I'm sick... so I like girls like me Skinny for me please!

the normal weight amy please........

I prefer the one on the right by a loooong shot. Although dropping a kg or two wont hurt.

lol I also thought she was black, with that soul voice of hers.
In the pic on the left she looks like Fran Drescher after a bout of crack cocaine

Right

The one on the left looks like Keith Richards

oh and give me Lily Allen over Amy ANY DAY!
(even though Lily admitted on live radio that she was going to celebrate her number one hit by doing a gram of coke)

Who's Lily Allen?

definately the one on the right with a few kilos shaved off...

smile
ldn
etc

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lily_Allen

She looks like she is stoned / wastede on the left.

The right is definitely better

OK, I think I know the song "Smile".

Maybe those pic on wiki don't do her justice, but I'd rather have the skinny Amy Winehouse

The worst looking skinny celeb is Hilary Duff I used to think she was the hotness, but now her face is way too skinny

*SIGH* life is so complicated ...........................especially when you are rich or/and famous

Paul: you could be her father

Hey... leave the man alone >_< There's nothing wrong with thinking someone's hot if they're over 15 Younger than that you just say: "She's got potential" LOL

Yeah, here's the video, she actually looks very good in the video...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LD5sahXoj0U

Mmm, I love Amy, I think she is an amazing artist, but she also just proves the old cliché of the "tortured artist," though her torture is self-inflicted, found these really disturbing pics showing her self-mutilation on the internet yesterday, she says:

Amy Winehouse told Rolling Stone that the slash marks on her arms could best be chalked up to the fact that she grew up in the shadow of her older brother, and read a lot of J.D. Salinger.

“I did a lot of that ‘Oh, life’s so depressing’ stuff before I was even 12. That’s when I would be reading J.D. Salinger… and feeling frustrated (sic).”

She is pretty disfunctional, haai shame, I wonder if she has any real friends to take care of her, and I have to wonder about the merits of marrying the person who inspired her entire BACK TO BLACK album, which, if you don't know, is an homage to all the messed-up things people can do to each other in and out of a relationship.







Ja, not only is she white, she is Jewish, a Jewish princess from North London.



Well, this is what she would look like with a kg or two "shaved off" versus her now...

http://www.mollygood.com/wp/docs/2007/05/w...5pa_468x693.jpg

Oh dear. Those slash marks are the clincher for me, nothing more than attention seeking and publicity IMHO.

Seriously, who plays a gig and purposely leaves shit like that on display? And what is that teaching her younger audience?

I never went all chop suey after reading Salinger

/me go slash my face maybe I'll get more sympathy! too!

she has an amazing voice, but I really don't care about her life.

Hahahaha
Paul ftw

Btw, wtf is wrong with winehouse in this video:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2vfdl7-E80Q...ted&search=

sheeesh - talk about being on stage shitfaced up to your eyeballs - I couldnt finish watching it

Damn those are some nasty photos, she looks terrible 'out of' her videos.

I wouldn't be able to decide whether to say hello or give her a sugar cube

How about a slap and a stay in rehab!

She needs to get her life back together. Her case is far worse than Paris Hilton's or Britney's ever was!

Hell yeah; exactly how I like my womens! mm mmm

.i dont know what u like in right one.i dont like both,but left with lil bit more fat would be perfect!



im skinny but i still got boobs and ass. how anybady could like those fatty bombas?i hete when fat bigs are wearing clothes for normal people... dont they understand that they look disgusting?ok, amy here is not soooo fat,but not far. i love my body,im working for it-yoga,jogging in morning , spa n stuff, but those big cows come n say-ooo,im soooo fat,im sooo sexy-
n dont say that im stupid. im smarter than most of people.thay dont know how hard is to be smart,beatiful n healthy in the same time




n fat is not healthy




hell yeah >:D

Ahhh, every generation has one.

The Flower Children had Janis...
I'm in my 40's, so we had Grace Slick...
Gen-X has Courtney Love...

She's smokin hott in the pic on the RIGHT though!

i wouldnt say "smoking" hot but I'd tap that

There need to be curves on a woman, but skinny to the point of gauntness really makes me sick. You say you got puppies and booty, well good on you, then it should be more than acceptable to skinnier than most women around you.

For example:



and:



and:



Now that is what i meant.

......

i'm speechless... lol

I don't know if that was really, really smooth or really, really creepy.

Rust is on the money (again)

That was moderately disturbing that Valhuru chose to stick that photo in!!!!

But on the other hand! Well Done that got our attention

for Valhuru

Hehehehe....

That right there is why the word "wolfpig" was invented

man bear pig comes to mind

the right definitely, the left reminds me of someone I saw recently living on the sidewalk sleeping on a blanket. the pic on the right looks about perfect to me.

I was unfortunate enough to find this picture of the swamp donkey.

She'd make a great poster child for a drug abuse campaign.

What the hell is wrong with her? She is incredibly talented...why would you waste something like that. I would imagine she enjoys performing but why then be wasted all the time. It makes me sick!

Wow, I didn't even recognize her from the picture on the right .. she looks so much healthier there (and less eye makeup)