Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Western Digital WD740ADFD: Bottled Lightning
Vault9 Forums > Tech Den > Techie Toys > Tech Talk

Custom Search
Fishfly
QUOTE
The original Western Digital Raptor was launched as the WD360GD in March of 2003 with an enterprise level 10,000 RPM spindle speed, SATA interface, 8MB buffer, 5.2 millisecond read seek time, and a single-platter design featuring 36GB of storage. While it shined in single-user performance, the drive did not fare well against its SCSI-based competitors in the enterprise server market for which it was designed. Its already small size and complete lack of command queuing abilities delivered performance that was not on par with the SCSI drives in the critical multi-user applications. However, due to the lack of entry level SCSI drives, a growing interest in SATA components, and a very avid computer enthusiast market, the drive was able to succeed until its replacement arrived.

The next version of the Raptor was launched as the WD740GD in December of 2003 and boasted several needed enhancements. These enhancements included the addition of another platter that increased the capacity to 74GB, 4.6 millisecond read seek time, a FDB based motor to address noise concerns, and ATA-4 tagged command queuing. While TCQ was a welcome addition and certainly improved the drive's I/O operations, it still was not a match for most SCSI drives in the enterprise market. This was primarily due to a lack of SATA controllers that fully supported TCQ and firmware that was not as mature as the SCSI competition.

However, this drive was - and in certain cases continues to be - consistently one of the faster single-user performance drives available. The computer enthusiasts flocked to the drive due to its performance advantages, but the drive continued to have limited success in the enterprise server market. In a nod to the success of the drive in the computer enthusiast market and acceptance of its importance, Western Digital offered the drive in retail stores for a short time. Over the course of the last couple of years, the 8MB cache drive has been enhanced with minor revisions with one of the latest versions, WD740GD-00FLC0, receiving tweaks that significantly improved its performance in single-user applications.


The last major update to the Raptor family occurred in January of 2006 when the WD1500ADFD was launched with a significant list of improvements. The drives still sported the familiar 10,000 RPM spindle speed, 4.6ms read seek time, and a two-platter design now at 150GB capacity. The platter's density was increased to 75GB+ and equals those of several 10,000 RPM SCSI competitors. The buffer size was doubled to 16MB, matching the latest offerings from other drive manufacturers. An OEM version of this drive was made available by Dell that sported a 160GB capacity. WD also introduced a limited edition Raptor-X that featured the 150GB version with a crystalline polycarbonate based transparent cover over the spindle and platter section of the drive.

The Marvell 88i8030 PATA to SATA bridge chip that was used on the previous Raptors was finally dropped in favor of a native SATA implementation. This native SATA implementation brings with it Native Command Queuing instead of the legacy firmware-level Tagged Command Queuing. While NCQ can have a favorable impact in multi-user applications, it can create a performance penalty in certain single-user applications. Since the drive is still targeted towards the server market, it retains the first generation 150MB/sec SATA interface instead of the 300MB/sec SATA interface found in most of the current consumer level drives.

The WD1500ADFD also introduced Time Limited Error Recovery (TLER) and Rotary Acceleration Forward Feed (RAFF) operations to the Raptor product family. TLER allows the drive to signal the RAID host adapter in the event an error recovery process has exceeded timeout parameters. This prevents false drive dropouts on the host adapter when utilizing RAID level 1 or above configurations. Although TLER is disabled by default, a utility is available from Western Digital to enable TLER. RAFF is an electronics feature that senses rotational vibration in a multi-drive setup and then compensates for it by controlling the drive head location. This feature is designed to keep read and write operations consistent, thus avoiding time consuming retries by the drive that could impact performance.

The latest updates to the Raptor family occurred last fall when Western Digital offered the same features introduced on the WD1500ADFD on its 74GB and 36GB drives. The current WD740ADFD also sports a single platter design now instead of the previous two platter design in the older series. We will be taking an abbreviated look at the WD740ADFD today as we received numerous comments and emails inquiring about the performance of this drive. Our next storage review featuring several of the latest 500GB drives will include full performance results of this drive and its smaller sibling, the 36GB Raptor WD360ADFD. For now, we think the performance results we will present today should give a clear indication of the drive's performance.


LINK

this has to be one of the fastest drives for any speed enthusiasts with limited cash can purchase!
CrEaTi0n
wow that is very fast! 4.6ms seek time.

/me wants one!!!
Fishfly
ye they sure are fast but only 1?

I'd rather have 2 and RAID it devil2.gif
cyfermaster
You always want 2 of things. You should have had a twin so you could be raided. tongue.gif

I wouldn't mind a few of these babies. smile.gif but as is the norm at the moment, there are no funds right now. sad.gif
W@RP@T}{
Me= poor

Would also love some of these, mebe like 4 of them smile.gif

thing is they are hugely schpensive for $ per GB
Fishfly
expensive? hell no have you seen the SAS drives? 2k ex vat dealer price... runs at 15k rpm 4ms seek time too!

http://www.directron.com/mau3073rc.html

Fudzy
What ms seek time do the standard Seagate Barracudas run at?
Fishfly
11/12ms for the seagate

seagate barracuda 7200.10 st3320620as with NCQ , 320gb, s-ata2 , 7200rpm, 16mb cache, 11/12ms - 5 years warrenty
naughty
QUOTE(Fishfly @ Feb 8 2007, 10:50 AM) *
ye they sure are fast but only 1?

I'd rather have 2 and RAID it devil2.gif


problem is if one drive gets corrupted - you lose all your data - i have been seeing a trend here - guys who fiddle a lot with their machines shouldnt run raid since the odds of losing your data just cos you unplugged the wrong cable is very high

id just buy a single 150gig raptor - is just around the same as two of these in raid - the raid setup may be marginally faster - but the risks are not worth it IMHO - nowadays i just use the raptor as my O/S drive - and all the others as storage - and keep those unplugged - and just plug those in when i need them - gonna buy an icydock 5 bay enclosure for all my SATA2 storage drives - have 3 x 320gigs now
cyfermaster
QUOTE
have 3 x 320gigs now

Show-off. sad.gif

I am not the biggest fan of raid either. I like your thinking naughty.
naughty
QUOTE
Show-off.


LOL - you really want to see showing off - see the O/S drive



another view



it came in a silk bag to prevent scratching



better pic of it - not taken with my phonecam .....LOL

cyfermaster
I ignored the O/S comment, as if I didn't I would have to kill you tongue.gif

where's the pics?
naughty
QUOTE
where's the pics?


what pics??? of the raptor??? ie thats running the operating system (O/S) - cant you see those above??? (we both probably posted at the same time) - or do you want pics of those 320's as well ??? - i only just add those in when i need to 1 at a time - thats why i want that icydock enclosure - just been looking at the external one - it seems very nice
cyfermaster
I can't see any pics. sad.gif

They must be blocked from work. I will have to check them out when I get home.
naughty
theres 4 photobucket pics in my above post - 1 from western digitals site - and the some done with my phonecam - probably is blocked at your work - not the clearest pics in the world - but they give you an idea of how the thing looks
Fishfly
QUOTE
problem is if one drive gets corrupted - you lose all your data - i have been seeing a trend here - guys who fiddle a lot with their machines shouldnt run raid since the odds of losing your data just cos you unplugged the wrong cable is very high
naughty I've been running raid since my 2x80gigs and there's no way in hell am I giving up my raid just cos people THINK it's unsafe... I cart my pc around to lans I've ripped my system out numerous times just cos I wanted to change something, switch something and the only reason why my raid would fail is if I use a different controller...

so far I've had 1 loss of data which came with my 2x120gig maxtor stupid shit drives there are if you ask me angry.gif

the tranfer rate at this point in time between my 2x250 and 2x160 sits at 100MB/s (burst copy) whilst my transfer rate between my 2x250 and 1x250 sits at 60MB/s I'm never going back to 1...

as for drives crashing, all you need to ensure is that your drives are cooled sufficiently stick a 120mm fan to blow on your drive and you will NOT see any problems.

P.S I've ran RAID since I had 2x80, 2x120, 2x160 and 2x250 on a NF7 board, DFI UT board, Abit k8n board, MSI K8N board and will be moving to the asus board! I'm more likely to loose my mobo's than my hdds sad.gif
naughty
still not worth the risk to me - ive seen too many posts where guys complain of losing their data - when SATA cables are more securely attached - i may think of it ie when they are springloaded for example like the eSATA cables - otherwise these things can move easily - and as a result corrupt the data

also the speed benefits to raid are so negligible in real life - i think i dont need to transfer a file around 30 to 40 seconds quicker when im doing a 4.3 gig transfer in 3 minutes already - but anyway if you like it then you should stick with it - its just not worth the risk to me personally - id like to preserve my data that its taken 7/8 years to collect
naughty
whoops sorry - double post
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Custom Search
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.